Section: Module 12: Lesson 1: From Cultural Competence to Cultural Humility | Humanism in Health and Healthcare | NextGenU.org

  • Learning Objectives:
    • Interrogate and discuss the limits of cultural competence as a humanistic enterprise in healthcare.
    • Analyze and describe the differences between cultural competency and cultural humility.
    Approximate time required for the readings for this lesson (at 144 words/minute): 27 mins
     

    Click here to start this lesson

    • Required Learning Resources and Activities
    • For several decades, there was a push to increase "cultural competence" among health care providers. This effort importantly was a recognition that cultural values impact patients and their families understandings of their illness, their underlying motivations for health care decisions, and interpersonal relationships with their health care team. Certainly, understanding how groups of people, particularly those who are often marginalized, tend to experiences health and health care can be an excellent starting point and provide important background knowledge (indeed, this is the motivation behind the previous lessons which explore different marginalized groups). However, there are implicity assumptions rooted in the concept of "cultural competence" that may, ironically, undermine its very intentions. Please read the article by Michael Paasche-Orlow in which he discusses some of the potential missteps of the concept of cultural competence. As you read, think about ways in which you've seen beliefs and attitudes of patients that are rooted in culture play out in the clinical setting. Is it problematic to think of culture as a static thing that patients "have"?

    • Please read the article by Lauren MacKenzie and Andrew Hatala. As you read, continue to think about problems associated with the well intentioned efforts to promote "cultural competence." Pay attention to the differences between "cultural competence" and "cultural humility." Do you think that cultural humility "solves" some of the problems of cultural competence?

    • To access the quiz, click on the name of the quiz provided above. On the following screen, click the "Preview quiz now" button to respond to the questions.